Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq war: realism versus neo-conservatism. Open source article – check for full text link won’t work. [ALL to review]. Add to My. 17 John J. Mearsheimer, “Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq War: Realism versus Neo-Conservatism,” , posted 19 May. Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq War: Realism Versus Neo-conservatism. Front Cover. John J. Mearsheimer. OpenDemocracy,

Author: Shaktirg Zuluzil
Country: Namibia
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Love
Published (Last): 11 December 2004
Pages: 395
PDF File Size: 19.12 Mb
ePub File Size: 8.8 Mb
ISBN: 489-8-34360-526-2
Downloads: 28705
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Gozuru

Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq war: realism versus neo-conservatism | openDemocracy

Vetsus power brings certain duties as well as certain restraints. The RMA is largely useless in combatting an insurgency, against which a large army is needed, as the Bush administration has discovered in Iraq. Neo-conservatives correctly believe that the United States has a remarkably powerful military.

In sum, the RMA was supposed to make bandwagoning work, which, in turn, would make big-stick diplomacy work, neo-conservatisk, in turn, would make a unilateralist foreign policy feasible. Morgenthau almost certainly would have criticised that policy and the impending war loudly and clearly.

If the United States emphasised diplomacy over military force, it could not act unilaterally very often, because jraq by definition is very much a multilateral enterprise. There is another problem with democracies portraying themselves as the white hats in the world: However, when you are at the other end of the Veersus rifle barrel, it usually does not look that way. Hans Morgenathau died in July Many argued during the Vietnam years that the fight was a war between democracy and communism that the United States could not afford to lose.

There are many reasons to think that spreading democracy with military force is not an effective way to build democracy in Iraq, or any other place for that matter. Realists, however, are well aware of the difficulty of spreading democracy, especially by military means.

But if a state has awesome military power and can rely heavily on that power to do business in the international system, then it will not often need allies. The United States not only has dirty hands from Iraq, but it has also engaged in barbaric behaviour of its own. We publish high-quality investigative reporting and analysis; we train and mentor journalists and wider civil society; we publish in Russian, Arabic, Spanish and Portuguese and English.


Here’s an example of what they look like:. Some forty years later, the Bush administration thought that it could turn the domino theory to its advantage. Democracies only act in a bellicose fashion when the black hats, invariably non-democratic states, leave them no choice. No true conservative would embrace such a grandiose policy. Lyndon B Johnson announced morgwnthau he would not seek re-election as president.

morgennthau The increasing death toll among US forces, and the widespread domestic opposition to the war, led Nixon and his national security adviser Henry Kissinger to devise a strategy of phased withdrawals of US troops and a transferring of security responsibilities to South Vietnam. The solution was obvious: In short, they will jump on the American bandwagon rather than risk death.

The American military, in their view, would swoop down out of the sky, finish off a regime, pull vdrsus and reload the shotgun for the next target. Your reading intentions are also stored in your profile for future reference.

This item appears on List: Your reading intentions are also stored in your profile for future reference. The renowned American foreign-policy realist Hans Morgenthau opposed realizm Vietnam war. In other words, it can act unilaterally, as the Bush administration often did during its first term. One should not underestimate how ruthless democratic America can be when pushed to the wall.

Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq war: Sections openDemocracy Free thinking for the world. Critics of the Iraq war would also say to the neo-conservatives that it would make sense to solve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict before invading Iraq. This item appears on List: It makes it easy to scan through your lists and keep track of progress. Realists are often accused of disliking democracy and even of being anti-democratic.

Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq war: realism versus neo-conservatism | openDemocracy

Please log in to set a read status. Not surprisingly, Morgenthau warned about the dangers of pursuing global crusades in making his case against the war in Vietnam. Here’s an example of what they look like:. The realists, however, anticipated big problems before the war began; in this, they have been proved largely correct. It is natural to conclude that he would have understood that this same basic logic applied to Iraqand thus would have opposed the Iraq war as fiercely as he opposed the war in Vietnam.


To set a reading intention, click through to any list item, and look for the panel on the left hand side:. Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq war: Realists tend to believe that the most powerful political ideology on the face of the earth is nationalism, not democracy.

After a succession of military defeats, the South Vietnamese army and state collapsed in Apriland victorious North Vietnamese troops entered Saigon a day after the US embassy there had been evacuated.

Neo-conservatives would answer that an American victory in Iraq would compel Yasser Arafat to sign a peace treaty with Israel. Thus, realists predicted that Iran and North Korea would not react to an attack on Iraq by abandoning their nuclear programmes, but would work harder than ever to acquire a nuclear deterrent so as to immunise themselves from American power.

Have you read this? After all, no state modelled on the United States would resort to terror. It was just assumed that democracy would sprout once Saddam Hussein and other tyrants neo-cpnservatism removed from power. Not surprisingly, Hans Morgenthau was an ardent critic of the American effort to democratise Vietnam in the late s and early s. Neither the neo-conservatives nor President Bush ever explained in detail how democracy was going to take root in the middle east, where there was hardly any history of democracy.

Hans Joachim Morgenthau was one of the most important political thinkers of the 20th century and one of the great realist thinkers of all time. The human, environmental, economic and social damage was incalculable, and much endures to this day.